Optimism makes us perpetual enemies of those future moments that do not meet our expectations, which means all future moments. It is when we expect nothing from the future that we are free to experience it as it will be, rather than as a disappointment.
— Joshua Foa Dienstag, Pessimism: Philosophy, Ethic, Spirit
Well, that’s an uncomfortable question. Accepting that people have more access to enriching material—not just books but great cinema, enlightening lectures, beautiful art, and everything else—and actively choose to ignore it in favor of various shades of slop is… depressing. If you have any kind of populist leaning, left or right, you don’t want to blame the public for their tastes. It’s more psychologically comforting to deny the masses all agency. “The phones” is a harder villain to grapple with because we choose to use them. We elect to doomscroll, brainrot, ragebait, and slopwallow. We create social media content. We are the problem with phones.
This is certainly an improvement on the usual denial of agency, but the question remains: why should it be depressing that people have access to the finest achievements of human civilization and nevertheless spend much of their leisure time enjoying frivolous entertainment? It would be depressing if you began with the assumption that people possessed some latent desire for intellectual and aesthetic refinement that only needed the right circumstances to flourish. But what reason did we ever have to expect that? Mankind has been failing to live up to its idealized potential for as long as idealists have been documenting it in print, and that predictability is a comfort in itself. The greatest luxury of being an amateur observer of human behavior, rather than a reformer, is that you can find the same spectacle fascinating that the reformer finds intolerable.
There’s a difference between expecting little of people and resenting them for failing to meet your expectations. The former can coexist comfortably with affection, tolerance, and even admiration. The latter is a recipe for perpetual indignation. Much of what popularly gets called “pessimism” is actually curdled idealism — essentially, a disappointed demand upon humanity. The misanthrope of this sort hasn’t stopped believing in an idealized humanity. He’s furious that the actual specimens refuse to conform to it. His contempt is proportional to the extravagance of his original expectations. The true pessimist, who expects ordinary people to be ordinary, can be much more generous toward them than the supposed humanitarian who professes to love mankind but cannot forgive individual human beings for their limitations. Some of the people most loudly lamenting humanity’s shortcomings might actually like their fellow human beings better if they thought less highly of humanity.
I, too, am disappointed at what amounts to countless missed opportunities. If my friends liked to read more interesting books, or think about foolosophical questions, imagine how many more fun conversations we could have! But that personal disappointment is no excuse for leveling a broad condemnation of humanity, or existence itself, for failing to live up to an idealized version. And even in my disappointment, I can recognize that I, too, am often a bad judge of what life would actually be like if I got my way. There is always the possibility that a world of more readers just like me would be unpleasant in some way that I can’t envision from my limited perspective. So rather than daydream about an idealized state of affairs, it’s best to do what little I can to interest this person in this book or this idea, here, today, and let that be good enough.