Happiness of the historian. — ‘When we hear ingenious metaphysicians and backworldsmen talk, we others may feel that we are the “poor in spirit,” but we also feel that ours is the kingdom of Heaven of change, with spring and autumn, winter and summer, and that theirs is the backworld — with its gray, frosty, unending mist and shadow.’ — Thus a man spoke to himself while walking in the morning sun: one in whom history again and again transforms not only his spirit but also his heart, and who, in contrast to the metaphysicians, is happy to harbour in himself, not “an immortal soul,” but many mortal souls.
— Nietzsche, Human, All Too Human
The past decade has seen a right-wing populist surge in opposition to the long-entrenched forces of technocratic liberalism. The insurgency has included an assertive stance of moral certainty against the presumed spineless relativism of effete liberals. R.J. Reno captured some of the spirit of the times in his (admittedly excellent) book, Return of the Strong Gods. What he implied, many rank-and-file have since said outright: Christianity is the one true religion, and we have had enough of tolerating the false rainbow gods.
Supercharged political eras are not known for their nuance. You’re either with us or agin’ us. Regular townsfolk are best advised to avoid crossing Main Street while the gangs are facing off. And so, like a gaggle of old retirees in their New Balance walking shoes doing laps around the shopping mall, I meet up with Nietzsche, Montaigne, Epicurus, and a few other stalwart companions for an early-morning walk, while the partisans are still sleeping. We question, we debate, we doubt, and we talk about the changing weather. Our backworld revival continues apace, with banners, anthems, and a chest-thumping certainty that casts any appreciation of flux as decadent weakness. All well and good. But even while the insurgents rout their enemies, life is already undoing their victory. History obeys no stop signs. New certainties ossify, are jostled by events, then fall and shatter. So it goes. There is nevertheless beauty in contingency for those with eyes to see. And as that blue-haired soyboy the Chinese Farmer once said, ultimately, who knows what’s good or bad?

